The Export Market Entry Test
A little exercise to consider before packing samples in a case and getting on an expensive flight.
My recent Substack that centred around Rohan Duggal’s ranked checklist of what distributors are looking for in a supplier – apart from good liquid in a bottle - has been one of my most popular. This prompted me to come up with a second one, with a different checklist.
What should a producer know about a market before approaching it with their bottles? When I was Associate Editor of Meininger’s, working with the brilliant Felicity Carter, we commissioned brief market reports, in which I was sometimes quite closely involved.
Some trade fairs, including ProWein and the Wines Unsigned sections of Vinexpo offer exhibitors basic information about key export markets; Again, I’ve helped to write some of these reports and have been gratified by the responses I’ve had from people who’ve taken the trouble to read them.
That’s not what I’m doing here (the material I researched for those reports naturally belongs to the organisations that paid me to do that work), but AI and a bit of effort should help you build your scores.
A little effort
This time there are twenty-five questions and 100 points to be won. You almost certainly won’t be able to answer many of them fully without doing quite a bit of research; that’s the point. Sixty-three of the points are about knowing and understanding the target market; the remaining thirty-seven are about being fit to prosper in it.
Treat this and the Duggal Distribution Test as a pair. If you think all involves a lot of unnecessary effort, I entirely understand and, if your ambition is only to sell a pallet or two in order to add to the number of countries where your wine is sold, I can see why some will think it not worth doing.
But if you rely on export and really want to build reliable sales in significant quantities across a number of markets, I suggest giving it some consideration.
A. KNOW (30 points)
Key buyers: how many are there, and which matter? (7)
Ideally, you should have names af every significant importer, distributor and retail buyer, and the five that are most relevant to your brand. Time spent on their websites looking at what they already sell in your category could save you a lot of wasted effort.
Market shares, wholesale and retail (6)
Which are the top five wines in any realevant category, by volume and by value, and what is going up rather than down? You would score full marks for getting the real numbers, which is very unlikely, but win a few for any useful current information.
On-trade and off-trade split, by volume and value (5)
They are at least two different markets - café chains against fine dining; supermarkets against specialists - with quite different margins. You cannot suppose that the mix is the same in Dubai as in Denver.
Online sales and direct shipping (5)
Can you, or your importer, sell direct? If not, what are the rules that prevent or restrict it? Are there workarounds? Markets where orders can be placed online but the wine has to be physically collected, and the Bordeaux châteaux that own Napa estates through which they sell their French wine directly, are both worth thinking about.
Regional differences (4)
Is there one market, as in Singapore, or two or more, as in Belgium, the UK (very London-focused, with Scotland as a secondary), the US, Canada or Germany?
Channel mechanics and the listing calendar (3)
How to get a listing? Is there one buyer or a panel, or a set of panels? Will you have to deal with ‘negotiators’ as well as tasters? How long might it take? When are buying decisions made; not necessarily the month you’d guess?
B. DEMAND (33 points)
Style and origin preferences (6)
People in the Netherlands do not share the same tastes as their German neighbours, which is why South African producers may do better by focusing on the former market. What kinds, origins and prices of wine sell? Park your preferences, prejudices and preconceived notions: the Brits do not generally like Bordeaux; they buy a lot of sweet, jammy Australian red that goes unmentioned by critics but is highly visible in retail stores.
The competition (8)
Which are the six bottles that are likely to be on the same shelf as yours at a similar price, and might possibly prove more attractive to the shopper? They might not be from the same region or made from the same variety or, increasingly they might even be a beer or an RTD; your competitor may not even be a wine.
Your price point (4)
How broad is the band of prices in which your bottle would sit? How big are the volumes for that price band and your category?.
Direction of travel (3)
Which way are tastes heading? Towards lighter, lower alcohol, no and low wines? Premiumising or downtrading? Judge by the numbers rather than by the trade press, which often reports the trend it finds most interesting.
Food-and-wine culture (2)
Is wine overridingly a mealtime drink? Or is it used as an aperitif? How often are purchases gifts? If there is no established food culture, don’t overfocus on it “Our Bordeaux goes perfectly with Asian cuisine: is meaningless in any case. Find occasions the country already has; Le Grand Noir is very popular at funerals in Ghana, where saying goodbye to loved ones involves large numbers of people and copious drinking.
Wine vs beer and spirits vs non-drinking (2)
What share of the alcohol market does wine have by volume and value? What proportion of adults never drink wine? How much do wine drinkers consume? Is that rising or falling?
Stories (5)
Having a thousand-year family history may, for example, create a more positive impact in one market than another (China vs US). Sustainability can be more of a box-ticking argument for the trade than a reason for shoppers who often claim to care but buy on price.
Packaging (3)
Screwcaps and lightweight bottles may work well in your domestic market and in some of the countries to which you export. But they may not be as well received elsewhere. Africa and Asia (and often the US) still like heavy bottles and traditional cork.
C. REACH (14 points)
Getting it in (3)
Who is allowed to import, what label registration or approval is needed, which documents, which port and bonded warehousing are best? And how many weeks from order to shelf. China: weeks, plus a label filing. India: months, and in most states, a need to register.
Getting it around, and back out (2)
Know about delivery times, minimum order quantities and whether one region can be served without a national footprint. And, if all goes wrong, consider the reverse route: returns, re-exports, and what withdrawal from the market might cost.
Samples (4)
Who is allowed to receive samples? In many markets they need to be sent to a licensed consignee. Duty and VAT are payable even on free samples and some markets cap quantities or forbid resale. Shipping can take four to six weeks, and heat and breakage can make the exercise pointless
Private label and local bottling (3)
Depending on the category, volume and price of your wine, you may increasingly be asked if you will ship it in bulk for local bottling and/or accept its sale under a retailer’s or distributor’s private label. This is especially true applicable to German discounters, UK grocers, provincial boards in Canada and Nordic monopolies’ tender ranges and their egna märken. Saying ‘no’ can mean no sale; saying ‘yes’ to bulk-shipping can mean losing control over quality (though not necessarily) and, quite likely, margin. Accepting demands for private label may help build demand/awareness for the style while undermining your chances of selling your own brand.
We have never sold le Grand Noir under a private label.
Grey market (2)
The part of the wine market nobody talks about – partly because it’s a grubby business in which some brand owners happily collude. Assuming that’s not your modus operandi, is your wine already in your target market unofficially, imported opportunistically and unofficially (obviously) from a neighbouring country, and quite possibly distributed online or under the counter at a price your importer could not match. Who is doing it, at what price, and in which channel. Full marks means you have taken the trouble to look
D. MONEY (18 points)
Excise and tax, at every level — 5. Understand how much tax will be added to the price of your wine. Is it national and/or regional? Is it specific (UK) or ad valorem (Australia)? Is it levied on volume, alcohol or price? In monopoly markets, add state margins.
Risk of change — 3. Exporters to the UK have experienced periods of stability followed by successive duty hikes, including in 2026. A 10% duty rise can move a £9 wine by more than its entire margin.
Discount patterns: the real price — 6. Again, the UK offers a good example of a market where huge percentages of sales are made at discounted prices – often on a cyclical basis. Are you prepared for that – including the impact on the perceived value of your wine in other markets now that the internet has made pricing transparent.
Ex cellar/FOB/Landed costs to the shelf — 4. Understand freight and tax costs, what each tier takes, and how the bottle you sell at your €3 comes to cost $12 or $15 in the target market. And how competitive that may or may not be.
E. LAW (5 points)
Government vs alcohol (3)
Is the state trying to reduce drinking, tax it, or promote its own industry? Has that changed? And/or is it likely to do so?
Advertising and promotion restrictions — 2. In France you cannot show people enjoying wine. In other regions, brands legally use sexy models to promote wine. In Scotland there is a minimum price rule that doesn’t apply in England. In other markets, discounting is forbidden. Understand the rules and social mores.
What the score means
Below 50
You really don’t know the market. Spend the entry budget on research, not on flights.
50 to 64
You know the shape, but not the numbers. This is the stage at which most producers book their travel.
65 to 74
This is pretty good, but not enough to warrant investing heavily in the market. Advance with care.
75 to 84
You now know more than most of your competitors, which puts you in a good position. But you don’t know everything.
85 to 100
Well done. Depending on how well you did in the Distributor Test, you should be able to choose your importer.
The multiplier
Rohan Duggal had a useful equation for the five categories in his test: PROOF × MONEY × PEOPLE × DEMAND × PROFIT. “If [any one of these] is zero, multiplication does something pretty simple: everything becomes zero.”
The same applies to this test, except this time the headings are: KNOW × DEMAND × REACH × MONEY × LAW.
The one where people most often score zero is the first, because a producer’s sense of a market is usually a memory of a holiday, a conversation with an importer, or a time-limited export grant.




